Skip to content

chore(provenance): review #536 package re-pin coordinate publication - #568

Closed
raylei50653 wants to merge 2 commits into
chore/536-package-repinfrom
chore/536-package-repin-republish
Closed

raylei50653 wants to merge 2 commits into
chore/536-package-repinfrom
chore/536-package-repin-republish

Conversation

@raylei50653

@raylei50653 raylei50653 commented Oct 10, 2026 •

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner

Review the runtime-coordinate publication for the #536 package re-pin independently from its implementation. The base is the source/evidence branch chore/536-package-repin; the diff contains only the canonical publication and an append-only archive with the exact outgoing canonical bytes. The complete payload lands atomically through #569 to main after this review.

Coordinate delta:

  • Implementation: 9ef960e0fd1683ee... → 9a0fe01a4645616a..., 294 members. Only shipping/entrypoint_pin.json changes; packaged README is prose-excluded.
  • Decision surface, identity semantics, environment, and runtime inputs: unchanged.
  • A fresh controlled gpu0 probe was captured at clean 9be8e043 into a scratch candidate, independently reviewed before canonical update. Behavior digest remains 2dabed0b...; the full probe object has a different build witness, whose actual extension and plugin hashes were checked. equivalence remains unproven.

check_runtime_identity_staleness.py --mode attested passes at final head 85008e39. The outgoing publication is preserved as runtime_identity.2026-10-10.9ef960e0fd1683ee.json. Publication still does not authenticate artifact origin or approve distribution.

The default CI workflow triggers only for PRs targeting main; this feature-base review does not start a separate default workflow. GitHub may show checks from #569 because both PRs use the same head. The primary PR owns that exact-head CI for the complete payload. Full local pre-push and installed-package evidence are reported there; missing checks would not be CI success.

Refs #536. Review boundary: docs/reference/runbooks/runtime_identity_republication.md §3.2.

Implementation axis 9ef960e0 -> 9a0fe01a; 294 members, only entrypoint_pin.json changes. The README is prose-excluded. Decision surface, identity semantics, environment and runtime inputs stay unchanged. Fresh gpu0 probe captured at 9be8e04 using build/; behavior digest is unchanged, build witness differs and both artifact hashes were checked. Independent candidate review passed before promotion. Probe equality is not semantic equivalence; state remains unproven.
@raylei50653

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

Final state: closed without merge — review evidence retained. This package re-pin coordinate review surface (head 85008e39e440082a9555ebfee947e17e67d5ce5e) is included in #569's merge commit b56ad9f4cd4d982fc3f0b293206a32f7c8675332 on main (verified with git merge-base --is-ancestor); it was never merged separately. Closing is housekeeping, not a rejection.

@raylei50653
raylei50653 deleted the chore/536-package-repin-republish branch November 13, 2026 11:09
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant