Skip to content

readme: the directory, with the notifiers split out - #45

Merged
pAulseperformance merged 4 commits into
masterfrom
rebalance/one-entry-per-job
Nov 17, 2026
Merged

pAulseperformance merged 4 commits into
masterfrom
rebalance/one-entry-per-job

Conversation

@pAulseperformance

@pAulseperformance pAulseperformance commented Nov 17, 2026 •

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner

A directory, not a shortlist. The previous version of this branch applied an editorial rule of mine ("one entry per distinct job") and deleted eleven services because a bigger one covered the same job. That is the wrong rule for a repo whose purpose is to name the options and let a reader choose, so it has been withdrawn.

What the branch does now

Restored, verbatim from the pre-pass file (16): 3Commas, Altrady, Cornix, Cryptohopper, Mizar, TradeSanta, Tradelab.ai, TradingView.to, Tickerly, ProfitView, TradingConnector, Misc Collection, Python Pine Bot Client, Instabot Trader, Fundingrate Backend, Autoview Chrome Docker Bot.

One removal stands, and it is not about audience: PSStrategyX was listed twice, once as an orphan above the ### Open Source heading and once in Closed Source. One product, one slot.

Moves, none of which remove an option (6): the four alert relays now sit in Alerts & Notifications (a reader looking for automation is not looking for a notifier), and two tools that place no orders moved to Development Tools.

Additions (2): an indicator-search MCP server (138 stars, MIT) and a strategy optimizer (60 stars, MIT), both from the measured gap in the thin sections.

Two repairs from the review: the section no longer carries a lone #### Python heading over three entries, and forex, indices and commodities is back in the text, because deleting TradingConnector had taken the only sentence that named those markets.

93 entries in 11 sections. awesome-lint 0, 0 dead of 94 probed, both checks green.

Still open

Tickerly's ?partner=1898 and TradersPost's ?via=1 are both the owner's own referral ids, added by the owner in commit 7f76207 on 2024-11-20, not from a contributor. TradersPost now carries † with a footnote under the section, which is what this repo's pull request template asks for. Tickerly is restored unwrapped; marking it the same way is a one-line decision.

The adoption metric (audience size per entry, so a reader can filter rather than have the list filter for them) is not in this branch.

Paul Mendes added 2 commits November 16, 2026 22:06
The list was lopsided rather than short: 35 of 92 entries were order-execution
tooling, and Libraries plus Development Tools held 5 between them. This pass
applies one rule to every row - one entry per distinct job, and the entry kept
for a job is the one with the broadest venue set, the most distinct audience, or
the open licence - and it moves four notifiers out into a section of their own.

23 rows changed, 2 entries added, and the count lands at 77 in 11 sections.
Nothing is removed for being commercial: what goes is a duplicate product, a
duplicate job, a deployment recipe, a list of bots, and one entry whose engine is
already listed.

Two entries were filed where they did not belong (a ratings reader and an AI
code generator), and one product held two slots including an orphan above a
subsection.

TradersPost keeps its referral id and is now marked with a footnote, which is
what the pull request template asks for; Tickerly's affiliate id went out with
the entry.

awesome-lint 0, check_links 0 dead, counter reads 77 entries in 11 sections.
…onnector covers

Two defects the review found in this pass, both mine.

The section was left with a single '#### Python' heading over three entries,
which is a navigation level with nothing to navigate between.

Deleting TradingConnector took the words 'forex, indices and commodities' out of
the section: no remaining description says those markets, and Pine Connector
covers them on MT4/MT5. A reader scanning for those words found nothing.

awesome-lint 0, 0 dead of 78 probed.
@pAulseperformance

pAulseperformance commented Nov 17, 2026 •

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

Verdict: merge, after the two amendments now on the branch.

Measured after the first push, and it found two defects in my own pass:

  • the section was left with one #### Python heading over three entries, a level with nothing to navigate between;
  • deleting TradingConnector took forex, indices and commodities out of the section entirely. Pine Connector covers them on MT4/MT5, and no surviving description said so.

Both are fixed in 2c8eeb9. The rest holds: a venue-token diff of the section before and after the pass loses only those three words (plus mt4, which is an artifact of 'MetaTrader 4' being spelled out), and the Kraken question was tested rather than assumed: AutoView names Kraken 8 times and AlgoWay 12 times, so no venue lost its last mention.

Stands on that.

The owner's definition of this repo is a directory: a reader decides for
themselves which service suits them, and the list's job is to name the options,
not to shortlist. The rule I applied in the previous commit (one entry per
distinct job) was my editorial taste, not the repo's purpose, and it deleted
eleven services a reader could have wanted.

Restored, verbatim from the pre-pass file: 3Commas, Altrady, Cornix,
Cryptohopper, Mizar, TradeSanta, Tradelab.ai, TradingView.to, Tickerly,
ProfitView, TradingConnector, Misc Collection, Python Pine Bot Client, Instabot
Trader, Fundingrate Backend and the Autoview Chrome Docker Bot.

What stays from the pass, none of which removes an option:

- a product listed twice is now listed once (PSStrategyX had an orphan entry
  above the Open Source heading and a second one in Closed Source);
- the alert relays moved to their own section, a reader looking for automation
  is not looking for a notifier;
- two tools that place no orders moved to Development Tools;
- two entries added from the measured gap (an indicator-search MCP server and a
  strategy optimizer).

93 entries in 11 sections. awesome-lint 0, 0 dead of 94 probed.

Also fixes: the section had been left with a lone '#### Python' heading, and
'forex, indices and commodities' had left the text when TradingConnector did.
@pAulseperformance pAulseperformance changed the title readme: one entry per job, and the thin sections filled readme: the directory, with the notifiers split out Nov 17, 2026
… filtering for them

The directory names the options; this adds the half a reader cannot see, and it
only prints numbers with a public source:

- stars and a repository's birthday, from the GitHub API (carrying a token, since
  the anonymous limit is 60 an hour for an IP this machine shares);
- boosts, read off each TradingView script page;
- the domain's first capture in the Wayback Machine, which is a fact about the
  domain rather than always about the service, so the column says "domain since";
- App Store rating and count from Apple's public search API, matched on the app
  name starting with the entry's name so a stranger's rating cannot land here.

Trustpilot is attempted and refused: it answers 403 to scripted requests from
this host, so its column stays empty rather than carrying a guess.

The page is generated to ADOPTION.md and lives on the health branch with the
link reading, refreshed by the same weekly job. Locally it is gitignored, because
there is one canonical copy and it is the fresh one.

check_links 0 dead, awesome-lint 0, and the first pass measured 25 repos with
stars, 23 scripts with boosts, 89 domains with a first capture and 9 App Store
ratings across 93 entries.
@pAulseperformance
pAulseperformance merged commit 7e3fd0e into master Nov 17, 2026
2 checks passed
@pAulseperformance
pAulseperformance deleted the rebalance/one-entry-per-job branch November 17, 2026 07:03
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant